I think youre both right, this ride has become far more of a training ride than a reliability trial and as I said in the above report, the guys at the front were treating this ride even more seriously than that. If you get full teams including 1st and 2nd cat riders trying to drop each other from start to finish then you're racing pretty seriously. My av.speed for the 30 flat miles to the half way point at Turner's Hill was quicker than my av.speed for the last circuit race I did at Hillingdon, which is amazing on open roads in traffic. That's not what Reliability Trials used to be like.
Catford cc are used to the same hardcore of riders turning up year in year out plus a few first timers, but the icy conditions early yesterday must have put a lot of people off. I think they have (wrongly) assumed that there will be riders in any given group who know the route.
Usually there is a much bigger turnout and a much steadier main group including Catford CC members who act as navigators. That didn't seem to happen yesterday probably down to the reduced numbers. That's fine as long as they produce an accurate route card but that doesn't seem to have been the case.
Maybe you could drop the organiser an email via their website at
http://www.catfordcc.co.uk. They're a very well meaning and 'agreeable' bunch at Catford CC and would appreciate your feedback if it helps them improve next year's event.